Episode 1963: Michael Shellenberger
The Environmental “Contrarian” Who Spreads Climate Misinformation
Michael Shellenberger appeared on JRE #1963 to discuss his books “Apocalypse Never” and “San Fransicko,” as well as his involvement with the Twitter Files. While Shellenberger presents himself as a reasonable environmentalist, his work has been repeatedly criticized by climate scientists for spreading dangerous misinformation about climate change.
Climate Change Denial Disguised as Optimism
Shellenberger’s central thesis in “Apocalypse Never” - that climate change isn’t as bad as scientists claim - has been thoroughly debunked by experts:
-
Yale Climate Connections found his book contained “logical fallacies, arguments based on emotion and ideology, the setting up and knocking down of strawman arguments, and the selective cherry-picking and misuse of facts.”
-
Climate Feedback reviewers determined his articles include “a mix of accurate, misleading, and patently false statements,” noting that while pushing back against climate doomsday scenarios can be useful, “to do so by inaccurately downplaying real climate risks is deeply problematic and counterproductive.”
-
Snopes fact-checkers found that scientists whose work Shellenberger cited directly challenged his interpretations, stating he misrepresented their research to support his predetermined narrative.
The “Censorship Industrial Complex” Conspiracy Theory
During the episode, Shellenberger likely discussed his involvement with the Twitter Files and his theory about a “censorship industrial complex.” While there are legitimate concerns about content moderation and government influence on social media platforms, Shellenberger’s framing has promoted harmful conspiracy theories:
-
He testified before Congress claiming a vast conspiracy between government agencies and tech companies to censor Americans, often conflating routine content moderation with nefarious censorship plots.
-
The FBI responded that “conspiracy theorists and others are feeding the American public misinformation with the sole purpose of attempting to discredit the agency.”
-
His work contributed to harassment campaigns against researchers like Renée DiResta, who was falsely accused of being a CIA operative based on misinterpretations of the Twitter Files.
Cherry-Picking Facts on Wildfires and Natural Disasters
Shellenberger frequently claims that climate change plays no role in natural disasters and wildfires, directly contradicting extensive peer-reviewed scientific literature:
-
Multiple studies have documented clear links between climate change and extreme heat events, drought severity, extreme rainfall, and increased wildfire areas burned.
-
He misrepresented a 2018 FAO report, which actually stated that climate change already has negative effects on crop yields, livestock production, and fisheries, particularly in developing nations.
Why This Matters
Shellenberger’s appearance on Rogan’s massive platform allows him to spread climate misinformation to millions of listeners. By presenting himself as a “reasonable environmentalist” while downplaying genuine climate risks, he provides cover for climate action delay and gives ammunition to those opposing necessary environmental policies.
His work has been eagerly embraced by climate change deniers precisely because he provides a veneer of credibility - a self-declared environmentalist saying global warming is “no big deal” - while playing fast and loose with scientific facts.