Home / Episodes / Episode 1346

Episode 1346: Zuby

anti-trans rhetoric gender identity culture war media bias

A Platform for Anti-Trans Rhetoric Dressed Up as Common Sense

TL;DR: Joe Rogan hosts Zuby, a rapper whose primary public identity is mocking transgender athletes, and treats his viral anti-trans stunt as a serious policy argument rather than the unscientific publicity gimmick it actually was.

Zuby (Nzube Olisaebuka Udezue) is a British independent rapper and podcaster. He has no credentials in sports science, endocrinology, gender studies, or sociology. His relevance to public discourse stems almost entirely from a 2019 social-media stunt in which he filmed himself deadlifting in a gym while claiming to “identify as a woman” to mock trans-inclusive sports policies.

The Centerpiece Claim: The “Women’s Deadlift Record” Stunt

Zuby framed his deadlift as having “broken the British women’s deadlift record while identifying as a woman” — and Rogan treats this as a serious data point about trans athletes.

What actually happened:

  • The lift was performed in a training session in his gym, not at a sanctioned competition.
  • Zuby himself has acknowledged the lifts “weren’t official records.” Wikipedia: Zuby
  • No powerlifting federation recognizes self-declared identity as a substitute for the eligibility rules trans athletes are actually subject to (hormone testing, transition timelines, sport-specific policy).
  • Outsports and other LGBTQ sports outlets noted the stunt misrepresents how trans inclusion in sport actually works. Outsports coverage summary

Why it matters: Zuby’s stunt is a strawman. It compares a cis man cosplaying a declaration to actual trans women athletes who, in regulated sport, undergo years of hormone therapy and meet federation-specific criteria. Presenting the stunt as evidence about trans athletes is intellectually dishonest.

”Zuby’s Razor” and the Dismissal of Trans People

Throughout the episode, Zuby promotes what he calls “Zuby’s Razor”:

“If someone has their pronoun in their Twitter bio, there’s a 95% chance you can dismiss their opinion.”

This is not analysis. It is a tribal shibboleth that tells listeners they can ignore the views of trans people and their allies on sight.

  • Pronouns in bios are most commonly used by trans, nonbinary, and gender-nonconforming people, plus allies — meaning the “razor” is a coded instruction to dismiss them.
  • The American Psychological Association affirms that respecting chosen names and pronouns is associated with improved mental-health outcomes for transgender youth. APA Resolution on Gender Identity Change Efforts
  • A 2018 study in the Journal of Adolescent Health found chosen-name use in multiple contexts was associated with a 56% decrease in suicidal behavior among transgender youth. Russell et al., 2018

Why it matters: Reducing a marginalized group’s basic request for respect into a meme that justifies dismissing them is the rhetorical engine of cultural backlash.

Joe Rogan’s Role

Rogan does not push back. He laughs along, amplifies, and validates.

  • He treats the deadlift stunt as if it were a meaningful sports-eligibility argument rather than a viral gag.
  • He does not raise the actual eligibility rules used by World Athletics, the IOC, USA Powerlifting, or any other governing body.
  • He does not bring on a trans athlete, sports physiologist, or endocrinologist to provide context.
  • He platforms “Zuby’s Razor” without noting that it is, functionally, a license to dismiss a marginalized group.

This is a recurring Rogan pattern in 2019: an unchallenged sympathetic interview with a guest whose entire public brand is anti-trans culture-war content, with no counterweight from anyone with relevant expertise.

The Broader Pattern: “Common Sense” as Anti-Trans Cover

The episode leans heavily on framings that present anti-trans positions as politically neutral common sense:

  • “I’m just asking questions.”
  • “It’s just biology.”
  • “Pronouns are silly.”

These framings ignore the actual scientific and medical consensus:

  • American Medical Association: Opposes legislation that restricts gender-affirming care and supports trans athletes’ participation consistent with their gender identity under sport-specific rules. AMA statement
  • American Academy of Pediatrics: Supports gender-affirming care as the medical standard. AAP Policy Statement, 2018
  • Endocrine Society: Performance differences between trans and cis athletes after hormone therapy are far more nuanced than “men competing as women.” Endocrine Society Clinical Practice Guideline

Real-World Harm

Episodes like this don’t exist in a vacuum. They feed an ecosystem in which:

Bottom Line

Episode 1346 is not a thoughtful conversation about sports fairness or gender. It is a friendly stage for a viral culture-war figure whose central claim — that a self-declared identity lets a cis man waltz into women’s powerlifting — is a strawman that no governing body actually permits. Rogan offers no pushback, no expert counterweight, and no acknowledgment that the people being mocked are a small, vulnerable population with documented mental-health risks.

It is the model that later episodes (Jordan Peterson, Matt Walsh, Abigail Shrier, James Lindsay) would scale up: anti-trans rhetoric laundered through “just asking questions” affability.

Previous critique #1323: Andy Ngo All Episodes Next critique #1349: David Sinclair