Home / Episodes / Episode 1093

Episode 1093: Owen Benjamin & Kurt Metzger

anti-trans rhetoric platforming bigotry conspiracy theories

Episode 1093: Owen Benjamin & Kurt Metzger

TL;DR: Rogan platforms Owen Benjamin — a comedian who had just been dropped by his agency for inflammatory anti-trans rhetoric, and who would soon become one of the internet’s most prominent antisemites and white supremacists — framing the conversation as a sympathetic “intervention” about his Twitter behavior rather than confronting the actual content of his views.

Owen Benjamin is a stand-up comedian who, by early 2018, had begun publicly attacking transgender people and the parents of trans children. Kurt Metzger is a comedian and former Inside Amy Schumer writer who had his own 2016 controversy over comments dismissing sexual assault allegations.

This episode aired March 19, 2018 — five months after Benjamin’s UConn show was cancelled over his transgender comments and his talent agency dropped him. It was later among the 100+ episodes removed from Spotify when JRE moved to the platform exclusively.

The Core Problem

This is not an episode where bad ideas accidentally slipped through. Rogan booked a guest whose recent public controversy was specifically about anti-trans rhetoric, and then gave him 2+ hours to defend himself to the largest podcast audience in the world.

  • Anti-trans rhetoric platformed: Benjamin had repeatedly called an NPR host a “child molester” for raising a transgender child and attacked gender-affirming care for minors. ADL profile
  • Sympathetic framing: Rogan staged the conversation as a “social media intervention” about Twitter addiction — treating the medium as the problem rather than the content of Benjamin’s views. YouTube: “Joe Rogan Stages Social Media Intervention with Owen Benjamin”
  • Career rehabilitation: After being dropped by his agency and losing tour dates, Benjamin used JRE’s audience of millions to reframe himself as a free-speech martyr rather than someone facing professional consequences for attacking a marginalized group.
  • Kurt Metzger context: Metzger himself had been in a 2016 controversy over Facebook posts mocking women who reported being sexually assaulted by comedian Aaron Glaser, costing him his job on Inside Amy Schumer. Vulture coverage

What Happened Next

The episode is best evaluated by what Benjamin became after Rogan gave him this platform.

  • 2019 platform bans: Benjamin was banned from YouTube (December 2019), Facebook, Instagram, PayPal, and Patreon for hate speech violations. Daily Dot
  • Holocaust denial: Benjamin now routinely engages in Holocaust denial, referring to it as “the Holo-hoax,” and posts fabricated Talmud quotes to push antisemitic conspiracy theories. ADL
  • White supremacy: The ADL classifies Benjamin as promoting “white supremacy, anti-Black racism, and anti-LGBTQ rhetoric.” He has endorsed Nazi policies concerning Jews. ADL
  • Cult-like following: Benjamin built a paid subscription audience (“Bears”) on alternative platforms where he promotes flat earth, Holocaust denial, dinosaur denial, and the claim that the transgender rights movement is a eugenics program. Wikipedia
  • StopAntisemitism designation: The organization StopAntisemitism named Benjamin “Antisemite of the Week” for his sustained campaign of Jew-hatred. StopAntisemitism

The Benjamin who appeared on JRE 1093 was already exhibiting the patterns that would lead to every major platform banning him within 21 months.

Joe Rogan’s Role

Rogan did push back on Benjamin’s Twitter behavior — telling him he was “addicted” and “not being nice.” That’s worth noting. But the substantive problems are severe:

  • He booked the guest knowing the controversy: Benjamin’s anti-trans comments were the entire reason he was newsworthy in early 2018. Rogan chose to host him in that context.
  • Focused on tone, not content: The “intervention” framing treated Benjamin as someone with a Twitter problem, not someone with views that harm trans people and their families.
  • No expert counterweight: No medical professional, no parent of a trans child, no trans person was present to respond to claims about gender-affirming care.
  • Audience reach laundered the rhetoric: JRE’s audience dwarfed any platform Benjamin could have reached alone. The episode functioned as career rehabilitation at exactly the moment professional consequences were working.
  • No follow-up correction: After Benjamin’s full descent into Holocaust denial and white supremacy, Rogan has not used his platform to revisit or repudiate hosting him.

Why It Matters

When a podcast with tens of millions of listeners frames an anti-trans bigot as a misunderstood comedian, it sends two messages: that the underlying views are within mainstream debate, and that professional consequences for hate speech are themselves the injustice.

Benjamin’s trajectory — from JRE guest to banned-everywhere Holocaust denier — is a case study in what happens when major platforms treat early-stage radicalization as a personality quirk rather than a warning sign.

Sources

Previous critique #1084: Douglas Murray All Episodes Next critique #1098: Eddie Bravo