Episode 1071: Steven Crowder & NotGay Jared

TL;DR: Rogan platformed Steven Crowder — a conservative provocateur who built a career on anti-trans content — and uncritically aired his selectively edited “undercover” footage targeting an LGBTQ health workshop, helping normalize transphobia as entertainment.

Steven Crowder is a conservative commentator and host of Louder with Crowder, not a credentialed expert on gender, medicine, or public health. By 2018 he was already known for “Change My Mind” stunts and undercover stings of marginalized groups.

This episode functioned as a friendly promotional stop for content that LGBTQ advocacy groups, journalists, and platform moderators have repeatedly documented as targeted harassment.

The Pride Center “Undercover” Stunt

Crowder and Rogan discussed Crowder’s then-recent video in which he, his wife, and associates posed as a queer couple to secretly film a healthcare workshop at the Pride Center of Vermont.

Claim framing: that transgender activists are “actively targeting children” and exploiting Medicaid to fund gender-affirming care.

What actually happened:

The workshop, “What the Healthcare?”, was a legitimate session helping trans Vermonters navigate insurance and Medicaid coverage. Seven Days VT
The resulting video was selectively edited to manufacture the “targeting children” narrative. LGBTQ Nation
YouTube ultimately removed the video at the Pride Center’s request over privacy violations.
The Pride Center reported subsequent harassment of staff and attendees after the video circulated.

Claims About Transgender Youth Care

Crowder and Rogan discussed gender-affirming care for minors, including hormones and puberty blockers, with alarmist framing about “three-year-olds” being transitioned.

What the evidence says:

No major medical organization recommends or performs medical or surgical transition on toddlers. Social transition (name/pronouns) is non-medical and reversible. American Academy of Pediatrics
Puberty blockers are reversible and are only considered at the onset of puberty, not in young children. Endocrine Society Clinical Practice Guideline
Gender-affirming care is supported by the American Medical Association, American Academy of Pediatrics, American Psychological Association, and Endocrine Society. AMA Letter to NGA
The DSM-5 (which Crowder waved around as a prop in the episode) explicitly notes that gender nonconformity itself is not a mental disorder; gender dysphoria refers to clinically significant distress. APA on Gender Dysphoria

Joe Rogan’s Role

Rogan didn’t push back. He laughed along, validated Crowder’s premises, and amplified the “transing kids” frame to his then-massive audience.

He treated Crowder’s covertly recorded footage as journalism rather than as a harassment campaign with a documented track record.
He failed to ask basic factual questions: who actually performs these procedures, at what ages, under what protocols.
He elevated Crowder’s “two genders” worldview without referencing any of the medical, psychological, or sociological literature that contradicts it.

This pattern — Rogan deferring to confident non-experts on questions of medicine and identity — is one of the most consistent criticisms leveled at the show and would repeat for years.

Crowder’s Broader Anti-Trans Track Record

Context matters when evaluating who Rogan chose to platform without challenge:

Multiple YouTube suspensions for hate speech and harassment related to anti-trans content. Media Matters
Repeated stunts mocking trans women, including drag bits and an incident that got him banned from Planet Fitness.
Documented pattern of infiltrating LGBTQ spaces to manufacture “groomer” narratives. Transgender Map
Helped popularize what reporters have called the “post–gay-marriage pivot to transphobia” as a conservative business model.

Why It Matters

Anti-trans rhetoric framed as comedy or “just asking questions” has measurable real-world consequences.

The Trevor Project’s 2022 survey found 45% of LGBTQ youth seriously considered suicide in the prior year, with trans and nonbinary youth at highest risk; respondents linked their distress to anti-LGBTQ policies and rhetoric. The Trevor Project
The FBI’s hate crime data has repeatedly shown rising anti-LGBTQ incidents, with anti-trans crimes increasing year over year. FBI Hate Crime Statistics
Episodes like this one helped seed talking points — “transitioning toddlers,” “groomers,” “indoctrination” — that later became central to legislative campaigns restricting trans healthcare and existence in public life. GLAAD Accountability Project

Bottom Line

Episode 1071 is not a debate about a difficult medical topic. It is a long, friendly platform for a professional anti-trans provocateur, with Rogan as an uncritical host. The harm isn’t in any single sentence — it’s in the legitimization.

Sources: